MLB player prop bets and odds for Aaron James Judge on Friday, May 9, 2025, as the New York Yankees take on the Athletics.

Judge leads the Yankees, and most of MLB, in several key batting categories. His 12 home runs are the most in the league, as are his 34 RBIs, 56 hits and 34 runs. In just 36 games, Judge has already amassed a WAR of 3.1, having been the main catalyst behind his team's early success.