Craig and Rodriguez, who placed third in Love Island USA 's season 6, recently broke up on July 27, a source told PEOPLE. Shortly afterwards, their drama publicly escalated in a series of Instagram statements, with Craig ultimately calling Rodriguez a "manipulative liar."

Beyond the Villa" alongside Rodriguez, confirmed their split after one year of dating with a cryptic statement.

Craig said the theories she has seen online surrounding their breakup don't match up to "how terrible, disgusting and disappointing" the situation is.