Anthonette Cayedito, a 9-year-old girl from Gallup, New Mexico, vanished under chilling circumstances on April 6, 1986, and her case remains one of the most perplexing disappearances in U.S. history. The night before, Anthonette had gone to bed after spending the evening with her mother, Penny Cayedito, and her two younger sisters. At around 3 a.m., someone knocked on the door of their family home. Penny later stated that Anthonette answered the door, and a man claiming to be
0:43
Anthonette Cayedito, a 9-year-old girl from Gallup, New Mexico, vanished under chilling circumstances on April 6, 1986, and her case remains one of the most perplexing disappearances in U.S. history. The night before, Anthonette had gone to bed after spending the evening with her mother, Penny Cayedito, and her two younger sisters. At around 3 a.m., someone knocked on the door of their family home. Penny later stated that Anthonette answered the door, and a man claiming to be
47.9K viewsJan 10, 2025
TikTokmystery_ofcentury
Exploring the Mystery of Anthonette Cayedito's Disappearance
8:50
Exploring the Mystery of Anthonette Cayedito's Disappearance
5.3M viewsDec 27, 2024
TikTokcrimewithkourt
The Mysterious Disappearance No One Can Solve!
1:12
The Mysterious Disappearance No One Can Solve!
1K views6 months ago
YouTubeTrue Crime Psychic Eye
Was there a CONFESSION? |The Disappearance of Anthonette Cayedito | Part 2 | Full Episode (S1,Ep4)
35:33
Was there a CONFESSION? |The Disappearance of Anthonette Cayedito | Part 2 | Full Episode (S1,Ep4)
81.4K viewsApr 9, 2023
YouTubeCrystal Gutierrez TV
El misterio tras la desaparición de Anthonette Cayedito
19:49
El misterio tras la desaparición de Anthonette Cayedito
27.3K viewsJul 3, 2023
YouTubePepe Misterio
Anthonette Cayedito- The 40 Year Mystery
11:30
Anthonette Cayedito- The 40 Year Mystery
96 views7 months ago
YouTubeDon't Be Shy True Crime
The 911 Call That Could Solve the Disappearance of Anthonette Cayedito
4:27
The 911 Call That Could Solve the Disappearance of Anthonette Cayedito
1.5K viewsAug 8, 2024
YouTubeHorror After Midnight
7:34
BEHIND THE SCENES: THE ANTHONETTE CAYEDITO INVESTIGATION
482 views2 months ago
YouTubeCrystal Gutierrez TV
20:24
Anthonette Cayedito: The 40 Year Mystery: Part 2
54 views6 months ago
YouTubeDon't Be Shy True Crime
1:36:20
085 - The Abduction of Anthonette Cayedito - UPDATED
29.2K viewsDec 25, 2024
YouTubeTrace Evidence Podcast
20:49
Possible Sighting Of A Missing Girl | The Search for Anthonette Cayedito | Part 4 | S2, E
63.7K viewsAug 21, 2024
YouTubeCrystal Gutierrez TV
0:26
Black File Archives on Instagram: "In 1986, 9-year-old Anthonette Cayedito told her neighbors something chilling: she was afraid to be home alone. That very night, she vanished forever. The story her mother, Penny, told was like a scene from a horror movie: a knock at 3:00 AM, a voice claiming to be an “uncle,” and two men snatching the girl into the darkness. But as the sun rose over Gallup, New Mexico, the narrative began to crumble. Why did her mother’s story change so many times? Investigato
17.3K views3 months ago
Instagramblackfilearchives
1:34
Unsolved: Anthonette Cayedito | The 40-second Call That Made Police Question Everything
720 views1 month ago
YouTubeWhatTheActualFiles
40:20
Woman Claims To Be Missing Girl | Anthonette Cayedito | Part 3 | FULL EPISODE| (S2, E1)
353.6K viewsFeb 3, 2024
YouTubeCrystal Gutierrez TV
25:32
Anthonette Cayedito: There's a knock at the door in the middle of the night and she disappears.
5.5K views9 months ago
YouTubePhoenixia
0:09
I have a confession… Penny was purchased purely for the American aesthetic🫣. This year we are focusing on classic living. I tried to find a guide for inspiration and couldn’t so I made one! And it’s free. And it’s beautiful! A little five page book of inspiration and lists on what classic living looks like, feels like, tastes like. I’m so excited about it and I think you will be too. Comment “guide” and we will send it to your email for reference whenever you need it! #vrilvideo #foryoupages #r
2.6K viewsApr 22, 2024
FacebookHillary \\\\ Tello and Rose
19:01
LIBRA; Don’t Freak Out But Someone Wants COMMITMENT From You, Get Ready For An UNEXPECTED Confession #tarot #tarotreading #viral #trending #libra
20K views2 months ago
TikTokpenny.tarot03
0:49
Dramatic video shows Jordan Neely being put in chokehold on a Manhattan F train, resulting in his death
May 6, 2023
NEW YORK POSTMatthew Sedacca
Murder trial hears Dean Penney's confession to fake 'crime boss' - NTV: Newfoundland and Labrador's Most Trusted News Source
3 weeks ago
ntv.ca
1:58
Top 10 Funniest Penny Scenes You’ll Never Forget 😍🤣 #Penny #KaleyCuoco #TBBT #FunnyScenes #BigBangTheory | Best Movie
1.1K views5 months ago
FacebookBest Movie
0:21
Cat Confession: You're Adopted
5.1M viewsJan 11, 2023
TikTokpennythegingercat
0:13
Confession time! How many of these spread habits are you guilty of? Drop your comments below 👇🏿 #GoldenpennySpread #NeverHaveIEver #GoodForTheFamily | Golden Penny Spread
83.3K views10 months ago
FacebookGolden Penny Spread
3:52
Mean girl gets payback 🎬 This video was produced by Network Media LLC and Penny Wiggins | Confessions Of A Kindness Queen
38.5K viewsApr 3, 2025
FacebookConfessions Of A Kindness Queen
0:35
Rod Stewart ,cheated, on Penny Lancaster when they first started dating
Nov 9, 2018
MIRRORJoel Cooper
0:50
Bride charges her bridesmaid $10,000 to be part of her wedding
Sep 11, 2023
NEW YORK POSTAsia Grace
1:30:22
Evil Girlfriend Realizes She Is Going To Jail Forever
856.8K viewsNov 3, 2023
YouTubeStranger Stories
1:00
PENNY CONFESSED TO LEONARD | THE BIG BANG THEORY
13.6K viewsAug 28, 2023
YouTubeComedy Quirk
8:14
Moments That Prove Penny Was the Real Genius
708.3K views1 month ago
YouTubeSitcom Vault
4:26
Murder trial hears Dean Penney's confession to fake 'crime boss'
22.5K views3 weeks ago
YouTubeNTV Canada
1:01
El caso que resolví… era el mío. #tusecreto #anecdotas #confesiones | confessions
420.3K views2 months ago
TikTokpreguntas_en_reddit_
See more